This article, published in Musical America, is essentially based on an interview of Eugene and Marta Istomin. It synthesized the plan and its prospects.
MEXICO n’est pas vraiment une destination de premier ordre sur la route des festivals, mais les événements qui viennent de se produire en octobre et novembre pourraient bien marquer le début d’un changement. Pendant plus de trois semaines, un voyageur dans cette capitale aurait trouvé un nouvel orchestre en résidence, une série de concerts avec l’Orchestre Symphonique de Londres, un défilé de chefs d’orchestre bien connus (Mehta, Semkow, Comissiona, Schneider, Torkanowsky, et Eduardo Mata, un enfant de Mexico, qui vient d’être nommé à Dallas) ; il aurait entendu des ensembles de premier ordre tels que le Quatuor Guarneri et le Trio Istomin-Stern-Rose, des solistes de haut-vol comme Pinchas Zukerman et Jess Thomas. Pour le moins, les premiers Concerts Internationaux Casals, qui ne se sont pas contentés de recruter des talents internationaux mais se sont donné beaucoup de peine pour mobiliser les musiciens mexicains et le public mexicain, ont rempli leur mission avec succès et n’ont nullement déçu. Dans le meilleur des cas, cela pourrait être l’étincelle qui donnera naissance à une célébration annuelle susceptible d’apporter un souffle nouveau aux activités musicales du pays, et de faire venir aussi un flot de visiteurs. En ce moment, il semble que tout cela dépende des Mexicains.
The Istomins: a helping hand
That the next move was up to the local citizenry was a point made quite clear by the two individuals who gave this particular festival its shape and character. Eugene Istomin and his wife, Marta Casals Istomin. The Istomins, of course, are practically the sine qua non in organizing anything which is to bear the name of Pablo Casals, but their role is far from honorary : they work like yeomen, their endorsement is enormously helpful in fundraising, and their professional associations undoubtedly have a good deal to do with the choice of soloists. But Eugene Istomin, who was artistic director of the Primeras Jornadas Internacionales casals, and Marta (honorary director) did not, in this case, seek their jobs – nor did they receive compensation. They have quite enough to do, one gathers, in attending to the Casals Festival in Puerto Rico – and the sailing there has not been smooth, as readers of this magazine are well aware. The idea of the Jornadas originated with Mexico’s former President, Luis Echeverria ( whose term expired in December) –or to trace it back a step further, it was prompted by a suggestion of the American journalist and author Henry Raymont, an old friend of the Istomins and a confidant of Echeverria. Since Pablo Casals had participated in Mexican musical life and had given the premiere of his oratorio, El Pessebre, there in 1959, a festival in his honor, to begin in the centennial year of 1976, was deemed highly appropriate. At the start, Echeverria hoped that the Istomins might be persuaded to shift their sponsorship from the existing Casals Festival in San Juan to one in Mexico City. This they decline to consider, and they take pains to point out that the two events are quite distinct – the Mexico City affair even avoiding the use of the word “festival” in its title, for the shake of emphasizing the difference. But the Istomins were willing to enter into planning an honor to Casals “under the proviso”, Eugene Istomin says firmly “that this be a new thing, and that it be designed to help the musical life of Mexico move ahead”.
This stipulation was fulfilled in a number of ways. Eduardo Mata, a Mexican, was appointed principal conductor and technical director. A festival orchestra was formed, drawing on the best manpower of several Mexican symphonies ( from Mexico City, Vera Cruz, Jalapa, Guadalupe, Toluca), beefed up by some imported players (about twenty-five percent) : Mexican salaries were raised to match the fees paid the outsiders. The ensemble was proud to be called the Orquesta Pablo Casals de Mexico – the only orchestra to bear the maestro’s name since the one he himself founded in Barcelona in 1919. In addition to frequent concerts in Mexico City, under Mata and the guest conductors, it performed five concerts in the provinces while the London Symphony was in the capital. And, in possibly the widest-ranging gesture of all, the festival authorities saw to it that the programs were carried on radio and television throughout the country – broadcast for forty-nine towns and reaching an estimated two million people. Understandably enough, local Mexico City television directors, not particularly accustomed to working within a concert format, quailed slightly at an undertaking of the magnitude. To insure the best possible presentation, the festival brought in in prize-winning New-York television director Allen Miller, who spent six advance weeks in Mexico training TV crews, and kept a close watch on production during the run of the concerts. Costs for the festival were met from three sources: one-third government funding, one-third private donations, one-third box-office.
It all added up to a heady three-weeks-plus. Concerts were held in the city’s somewhat ramshackle Palacio de Bellas Artes – all Napoleonic grandeur on the outside and decaying art-deco inside – and were repeated at very low prices in the 3,500 – seat Teatro Metropolitan, a movie theater, where crowds lined up for tickets. One of the Guarneri Quartet performances took place in the dazzling bright-gold rococo interior of a restored Jesuit church in Tepozotlan, an hour’s drive out of town. The festival repertory (skirting Mexico composers like the plague – a matter that would bear some adjustment in the future) was solid and middle of the road – a Mahler Fourth with the Pablo Casals Orchestra under Mata, the Brahms Violin Concerto with stern, Wagner excerpts with Jess Thomas, all-Beethoven and all-Tchaikovsky programs by the LSO, with Istomin and Zukerman as soloists, respectively.
Mata: a firm hold
My own trip to Mexico City encompassed a silken but softboned performance by the Guarneri Quartet of Beethoven’s Opus 59, No. 1, and a fluid, flowing Stravinsky Concertino; and in the Bellas Artes, the Pablo Casals Orchestra under Mata in a performance of Stravinsky’s Symphony of Psalms and Mozart’s Grand Mass in D minor, with Heather Harper, Benita Valente, Michael Best and Gary Kendall, the soloists. The orchestra under Mata’s firm hold made a good showing and the solo singers, especially Mmes. Harper and Valente, were a joy to hear. Two choruses (from the national School of Music in Mexico City and the Niños Canores of Puebla) sailed into the wind indomitably but were hard put to it. Nobody, however, thought of begrudging their share in the festival, and with more opportunity to perform on a scale doubtless some of the rough edges, could be smoothed. That, after all, is the kind of local involvement Eugene Istomin had in mind.
The Istomins aren’t going out on a limb just now in regard to their share in the future of this undertaking. “We don’t want to institutionalize our part in this” is the way Istomin puts it. “To get our friends to come down, that’s OK for awhile. But I am in the good years of my life and I’m a performing musician. I would prefer to speak through my piano playing. At least this year has been an injection – a Hypodermic of high quality. The Mexicans must continue it. Whether it will even keep its name, I can’t say. A Casals festival must fit into his view, and this may not suit the people here. But the Mexicans have the opportunity to develop this into the first international music festival in Latin America.” Although nobody said so specifically, the interest and backing of Mexico’s new President, Jose Lopez Portillo, will have an important bearing on future plans.
Shirley Fleming (1929-2005) was an American music critic, who has been the editor of Musical America from 1967 to 1991 and contributed to the New York Post from 1978 to 2005.
Beethoven, Symphony No. 7. London Symphony Orchestra, Eduardo Mata. Concert filmed by Mexican television during the Primeras Jornadas Internacionales Casals. November 10 or 11, 1976